top of page
  • Writer's pictureMuammar Reed

Who's to Blame in a Car Accident: Understanding Fault in California

Car accidents can happen to anyone, and understanding who is at fault is crucial for legal, insurance, and financial reasons. In California, determining liability in a car accident is a vital aspect of the post-accident process. This article explores the key considerations regarding fault in California car accidents.

1) How to Determine Who Is at Fault in a Collision?

California, like many other states, follows a system of comparative negligence when determining fault in car accidents. This system assesses the responsibility of each party involved in the accident based on their actions and behavior leading up to the collision.

To determine fault, various factors are considered, including:

- Violations of traffic laws: Did either driver involved in the accident break any traffic laws, such as speeding, running a red light, or failing to yield the right of way?

- Witness statements: Statements from impartial witnesses can help establish the sequence of events leading to the accident.

- Evidence at the scene: Physical evidence like skid marks, damage to the vehicles, and the accident location can provide important clues.

- Police reports: Law enforcement officers at the scene may compile an accident report that includes their assessment of fault.

The most common traffic law violations we see in California are:

Cal. Vehicle Code Section 22350 (Speeding);

Cal. Vehicle Code Section 21801 (Left Turns & U-Turns);

Cal. Vehicle Code Section 21453 (Failure To Stop At A Red light);

Cal. Vehicle Code Section 21703 (Following Too Closely).

2) What Does "Fault" Mean in Insurance?

In the context of car insurance, "fault" refers to the determination of which driver is responsible for causing the accident. The at-fault driver is typically liable for damages, including vehicle repairs and medical bills, sustained by the other parties involved in the accident.

In California, insurance companies use the determination of fault to allocate liability for financial compensation. The at-fault driver's insurance policy typically covers the losses suffered by the other parties.

3) What Is a No-Fault Car Accident?

California is not a "no-fault" insurance state. In "no-fault" states, each driver's insurance covers their own injuries and damages, regardless of who is at fault. In contrast, California follows a traditional fault-based system, meaning the at-fault driver's insurance pays for the losses incurred by the other parties involved in the accident.

4) Who Determines Liability in a Car Accident?

Liability for a car accident is determined by a combination of factors. In many cases, the involved parties and their insurance companies will negotiate and come to a settlement agreement. If an agreement cannot be reached, a court (or a jury) may become involved to make a determination of fault. This determination may be based on evidence presented, witness statements, and other relevant information.

5) Who Is Liable for Medical Bills?

In a car accident, the party at fault is typically responsible for covering the medical bills of the injured parties. However, California follows the "pure comparative fault" system, meaning that the injured party's compensation may be reduced if they are found partially at fault for the accident.

For example, if you were found 20% at fault for the accident, your compensation for medical bills and other damages would be reduced by 20%. It's crucial to have a clear understanding of how liability is determined in your specific case, as it can have a significant impact on your financial recovery.


Understanding who's to blame in a car accident in California is essential for protecting your rights and ensuring fair compensation for any injuries or damages you may have suffered. The process of determining fault involves various factors, including traffic laws, witness statements, and evidence at the scene. Insurance companies, legal professionals, and sometimes the court system play a role in this determination. It's crucial to consult with an experienced attorney to navigate the complexities of California's fault-based system and ensure a fair resolution to your car accident case.

This article is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Each case is different and it is recommended that you consult a licensed attorney in your area if you have been injured or have a potential personal injury case.

10 views0 comments


bottom of page